Refugee Immigration Appeals in Canada

Canada offers refugee protection to individuals who face serious risks in their home countries. When the RPD refuses a refugee claim, Canadian law allows certain applicants to appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division to challenge that decision. These appeals give claimants a vital opportunity to correct legal or factual errors made in the original ruling.

Understanding the appeal process, meeting strict legal deadlines, and submitting strong evidence are critical steps in protecting your rights and improving your chances of a successful outcome.

Refugee Protection Division (RPD) Decisions

The Refugee Protection Division (RPD) of the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (IRB) decides refugee claims made by foreign nationals inside Canada. The RPD functions like a court, assessing evidence, testimony, and country conditions to determine whether an applicant qualifies for refugee protection.

When the RPD refuses a refugee claim, the claimant may have the right to appeal the decision, depending on their circumstances.

Appealing to the Refugee Appeal Division (RAD)

If the RPD rejects a refugee claim, eligible refugee claimants can appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division (RAD). The RAD reviews the RPD’s decision and determines whether it contains errors of law, fact, or mixed law and fact.

Most RAD appeals are conducted on the record, meaning the RAD reviews written submissions rather than holding an oral hearing. In limited situations, the RAD may schedule a hearing if credibility or fairness issues arise.

The RAD has the authority to:

1) Confirm the RPD decision.

2) Set aside the decision and grant refugee protection.

3) Refer the case back to the RPD for reconsideration.

Presenting a Strong Refugee Appeal

Success at the Refugee Appeal Division depends heavily on clear legal arguments and proper documentation. Appellants must submit a complete appeal record that clearly explains why the RPD decision was incorrect.

To support refugee applicants, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) provides information sessions at select regional offices. These sessions help appellants understand deadlines, filing requirements, and procedural rules.

Although helpful, information sessions do not replace legal advice. Professional guidance ensures that appeal records comply fully with RAD rules and timelines.

Who Cannot Appeal to the RAD

Not all refugee claimants have the right to appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division. You cannot appeal to the RAD if:

1) You are a Designated Foreign National (DFN).

2) The RPD found your claim to have no credible basis.

3) The RPD determined your claim was manifestly unfounded.

4) You withdrew your refugee claim, or the RPD declared it abandoned.

5) The IRB received your claim before the current refugee protection provisions came into force.

If you are not eligible for a RAD appeal, other legal remedies, such as judicial review at the Federal Court, may still be available.

Responding to the Minister’s Appeals

In some cases, the RPD grants refugee protection, but the Minister of Immigration appeals to the RAD. As the protected person, you have the legal right to respond.

Failing to respond allows the RAD to decide the case based solely on the Minister’s submissions and the RPD record. A timely and well-prepared response is essential.

Steps to Respond to a Minister’s Appeals

To respond correctly, you must:

1) File a Notice of Intent to Respond.

2) Prepare a Respondent’s Record.

3) Serve both documents on the Minister and submit them to the RAD within 15 days of receiving the appeal.

4) Provide proof that you delivered the documents to the Minister.

5) Ensure all documents meet RAD formatting requirements.

6) Submit all materials within the prescribed deadlines.

If you fail to follow RAD procedures, the division may refuse to consider your response.

How to Succeed in Refugee Immigration Appeals

To succeed in a refugee appeal, you must demonstrate that the RPD made an error in law, fact, or both. Strong appeals clearly identify these mistakes and support arguments with reliable evidence. Key factors that improve appeal outcomes include:

1) Well-organised documentary evidence

2) Clear legal arguments tied to the RPD’s reasoning

3) Compliance with all RAD deadlines

4) Copies of all documents served on both the RAD and the Minister

5) Experienced legal representation

Refugee appeals involve complex legal standards and procedural rules. Proper preparation significantly increases the chances of success.

Why Professional Legal Support Matters

Refugee immigration appeals are highly technical. Missed deadlines, incomplete records, or weak legal arguments can result in permanent refusal. Working with an experienced Canada immigration consultant ensures you present your appeal clearly, accurately, and persuasively.

Spike Immigration assists clients at every stage of the refugee appeal process, from assessing eligibility to preparing detailed submissions and responding to the Minister’s appeals.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is a refugee immigration appeal?

A refugee immigration appeal allows eligible claimants to challenge an adverse RPD decision before the Refugee Appeal Division.

How long do I have to file a RAD appeal?

Strict deadlines apply. Applicants must file most appeals within 15 days of receiving the RPD decision.

Does the RAD hold hearings?

Most appeals proceed on written submissions. The RAD schedules hearings only in limited circumstances.

Can I submit new evidence to the RAD?

Yes, but only if the evidence was not reasonably available at the time of the RPD hearing or addresses a grave error.

What happens if the RAD allows my appeal?

The RAD may grant refugee protection or send the case back to the RPD for reconsideration.

What if the RAD dismisses my appeal?

You may still request judicial review at the Federal Court, subject to eligibility and timelines.

+1-(647)-540-5496

Education Coaching

Free Online Assessment